Evaluating the Use of Steps and Ladders on UK Construction Sites: Advantages, Disadvantages, and Alternatives

Ladders and steps have been essential tools in the construction industry for centuries, providing workers with versatile solutions for accessing elevated areas. However, concerns about their safety and efficiency have prompted discussions on whether these tools should continue to be a mainstay on UK construction sites. In this article, we will impartially explore the advantages and disadvantages of both ladders and steps, while also considering alternative access solutions. Our aim is to shed light on this interesting debate in the context of the UK construction landscape.

Advantages of steps and ladders

Ladders and steps offer several advantages that have contributed to their widespread use on construction sites. Firstly, they are highly portable and can be easily moved around, allowing workers to access different areas quickly. This mobility is particularly valuable when tasks require accessing multiple points within a short time frame. Additionally, their straightforward design means that workers require minimal training to use them effectively, making them accessible to a wide range of professionals. Moreover, ladders and steps are cost-effective compared to more complex access solutions, which makes them a preferred choice for smaller projects or tasks that involve intermittent access.

Ladders and steps provide flexibility in terms of height. They are available in various sizes and configurations, allowing workers to reach different elevations without the need for intricate adjustments. This adaptability is particularly useful in scenarios where specific heights need to be accessed rapidly, such as during maintenance or repair work.

Here at THX, we offer a range of ladders available for hire today with next day delivery.

Disadvantages of steps and ladders

While ladders and steps have a number of merits, it is essential to acknowledge their limitations and potential hazards. One of the primary concerns is the risk of falls, which can lead to severe injuries or even fatalities. Both ladders and steps have relatively narrow bases, which can result in instability if not positioned correctly or on uneven surfaces. This instability makes workers susceptible to slips and accidents. TB Davies highlight an average of 515 injuries per year from workers falling from ladders. Additionally, the absence of a secure working platform increases the risk of falls and limits the ability to work with tools and materials efficiently, potentially compromising both productivity and the quality of work.

Both ladders and steps may not be ideal for tasks requiring prolonged or continuous access at height. The need to frequently ascend and descend these tools can be physically demanding and time-consuming, impacting worker fatigue and overall project timelines. Furthermore, tasks that involve carrying heavy tools or materials can raise safety concerns and hinder worker performance while using ladders and steps.

alternative access solutions

Given the drawbacks associated with ladders and steps, exploring alternative access solutions could be necessary. One solution is the use of scissors lifts. These provide a stable and secure platform for workers, enabling them to perform tasks safely at height. These lifts offer increased stability and are equipped with safety features such as guardrails and harness attachment points, significantly reducing the risk of falls. Additionally, many scissors’ lifts are versatile, allowing workers to access various heights and positions, thus enhancing overall productivity. For lower-level access requirements, push-around-verticals (PAVs) are a safe alternative, with versatile and cost-effective solution for a multitude of construction projects. They are compact, easy to handle, and designed to be safe, stable, and simple to operate. Unlike ladders, which can be prone to movement and tipping over, PAVs have a wide base and wheels that can be locked in place for added stability.

View our 6 best practice tips for Powered Access on-site

MEWPS

Mobile elevated work platforms (MEWPs), including cherry pickers and boom lifts, offer a flexible and secure access solution. These machines provide a stable platform with adjustable height capabilities, allowing workers to reach elevated areas safely. MEWPs are particularly beneficial for large-scale projects where access is required at various heights or locations. Their increased manoeuvrability and operability by trained personnel ensure optimal safety.

Podiums and mobile access towers

Podiums and Mobile Access Towers present another viable alternative. Providing a sturdy and spacious working platform that can accommodate multiple workers and heavy equipment simultaneously. These low-level access solutions offer enhanced stability and can be adjusted to suit the specific requirements of a construction project. While the set up may require more time and effort compared to using ladders and steps, it provides a significantly safer and more convenient working environment. Additional safety measures, such as safety netting or edge protection systems, can be implemented to further mitigate the risk of falls.

THX offer a comprehensive range of access equipment, from our signature HiViz Towers, to Powered Access and Push Around vehicles (PAVs).

summary

In the context of UK construction sites, evaluating the use of ladders and steps is a process that involves consideration for both their advantages and disadvantages, as well as the available alternatives. While ladders and steps offer portability, affordability, and ease of use, their apparent risks must be understood. Scissors lift, push-around-verticals, towers, podiums, and mobile elevated work platforms offer credible alternatives that prioritise safety and productivity.

As a tool and equipment hire company, we understand at THX the importance of providing construction workers with the most suitable access solutions. Factors such as cost, efficiency, and safety should guide the selection process. A comprehensive approach that takes into account the specific requirements of each construction project is necessary to determine whether ladders and steps are sufficient, or if they can be replaced with alternative access solutions. By focusing on safety and efficiency, the construction industry can work towards creating a more secure and productive working environment for all professionals involved.

Visit THX today and get in touch with a member of our team to discuss your specific requirements and experience stress-free tool and equipment hire, with next day delivery and guaranteed two-hour delivery slots.

30th Aug 2023